- Production DesignBeaten by Dale Hennesy: Walter M. Scott, Jack Martin Smith and Stuart A. Reiss for Fantastic Voyage
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Robert Clatworthy: Joseph Kish for Ship of Fools
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Robert Clatworthy: Joseph Kish for Ship of Fools
- Production DesignBeaten by Boris Juraga: Walter M. Scott, Elven Webb, Herman A. Blumenthal, Hilyard M. Brown, Jack Martin Smith, John DeCuir, Maurice Pelling, Paul S. Fox and Ray Moyer for Cleopatra
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Gene Callahan for America America
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Gene Callahan for America America
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Alexander Golitzen and Henry Bumstead: Oliver Emert for To Kill a Mockingbird
- Production DesignBeaten by Boris Leven: Victor A. Gangelin for West Side Story
- Production DesignBeaten by Boris Leven: Victor A. Gangelin for West Side Story
- Production DesignBeaten by Alexander Golitzen, Eric Orbom ( Posthumous Award ); : Russell A. Gausman and Julia Heron for Spartacus
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Alexandre Trauner: Edward G. Boyle for The Apartment
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by George W. Davis: Walter M. Scott, Lyle R. Wheeler and Stuart A. Reiss for The Diary of Anne Frank
- Production DesignBeaten by E. Preston Ames: Henry Grace, F. Keogh Gleason and William A. Horning ( Posthumous Award ) for Gigi
- Production DesignBeaten by Ted Haworth: Robert Priestley for Sayonara
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Cedric Gibbons, F. Keogh Gleason and Malcolm Brown: Edwin B. Willis for Somebody Up There Likes Me
- Production DesignBeaten by John Decuir: Walter M. Scott, Lyle R. Wheeler and Paul S. Fox for The King and I
- Production Design (Black and White)Shared with Arthur Krams and Tambi Larsen: Samuel M. Comer
- Production DesignBeaten by Jo Mielziner: Robert Priestley and William Flannery for Picnic
- Production DesignBeaten by John Meehan: Emile Kuri for 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Richard Day for On the Waterfront
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Richard Day for On the Waterfront
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Cedric Gibbons, Edward Carfagno: Edwin B. Willis and Hugh Hunt for Julius Caesar
- Production Design (Black and White)Beaten by Cedric Gibbons, Edward Carfagno: Edwin B. Willis and F. Keogh Gleason for The Bad and the Beautiful
























